The crime of punishment attracted much attention and some controversy when it was published in 1968. Aug 28, 2008 author of the human mind, the crime of punishment, theory of psychoanalytic technique, man against himself, the vital balance, love against hate, karl a. Karl menninger kansapedia kansas historical society. Karl menningers the crime of punishment williamson. Hopefully, as we progress morally and scientifically, we will adopt a therapeutic model for antisocial behavior, rather than our archaic retributionist model. Hello fellow wikipedians, i have just modified 2 external links on karl menninger. Menninger, 19461965 by karl a menninger book focus on karl menninger. Karl menningers new book starts with the as sertion that the criminal is not so much the exception. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. He advocated treating offenders like the mentally ill.
The menningers philosophy that psychiatry is a legitimate science and that the difference between a normal individual and a person with a mental illness is but a matter of degree was expounded in karl menningers first book, the human mind 1930, which became a best seller. The crime of punishment by karl menninger librarything. Menninger put it, those who asked us to spare a thought for the victims were being melodramatic. The crime of punishment by karl menninger national. This widely circulated books central idea is that punishment as practiced in penal settings is an injustice amounting to a crime. Prison reform and karl menningers, the crime of punishment. The life process in mental health by karl menninger 19631112.
In 1968, karl menninger, a highly visible and vocal u. A celebration issue for his 90th birthday bulletin of the menninger clinic man against himself by karl a. Reading karl menninger of the crime of punishment and. From topeka and back again the eldest of three sons of dr. With menninger s scrawled signature and date 51269. But in his day, he was an important public intellectual. The crime of punishment has been published at 1968 ed 1966. He examines the entire juridical system and its functions. In his first book, the human mind, menninger argued that psychiatry was a science and that the mentally ill were only slightly different from healthy individuals. His books included the vital balance, the human mind, the crime of punishment, man against himself, and love against hate. The crime of punishment by karl menninger 9780670002740. Karl menninger humanitarian psychiatrist infinite fire.
Karl menninger wrote his landmark book the crime of punishment reflecting his extensive experience as a practitioner in the courts as well as. Review of the book the crime of punishment, by karl menninger, m. Author of the human mind, the crime of punishment, theory of psychoanalytic technique, man against himself, the vital balance, love against hate, karl a. While menninger specialized in neurology and psychiatry, he built an international reputation through his writing. As a young man menninger was inspired by his dentist who mentioned that anyone would be honored to work with dr. This widely circulated book s central idea is that punishment as practiced in penal settings is an injustice amounting to a crime. Karl augustus menninger was born on july 22, 1893, in topeka, to charles frederick and florence vesta kinsley menninger. These days most people dont remember psychiatrist karl menninger. Nov 21, 2018 these days most people dont remember psychiatrist karl menninger. His 1966 book the crime of punishment argued that all punishment is. Karl augustus menninger, the last living pioneer of american psychiatry who radically transformed the nations views on the mentally ill, died wednesday morning of abdominal cancer. Charles frederick menninger, a country doctor, and the former flora knisely, karl menninger was born in topeka on july 22, 1893. Menninger dissected the criminal justice system and concluded, i suspect that all the crimes committed by all the jailed criminals do not equal in total social damage.
Oct 03, 2007 the crime of punishment, originally published in 1966, addressed the critical issue of crime in america and how we punish criminals. The cofounder of the menninger clinic in topeka, kan. A former professor of criminology and an officer of the american league to abolish capital punishment, menninger believed that there may be less violence today than there was 100 years ago but that it is now better reported. Menninger correspondence, the selected correspondence of karl a. Karl menningers main attack is directed to the vengeance or punishment seeking principles underlying prevailing penal systems of the united states, a very primary value of the book lies in the depth and explicit. Menninger dissected the criminal justice system and concluded, i suspect that all the crimes committed by all the jailed criminals do not equal in total social damage that. The crime of punishment, originally published in 1966, addressed the critical issue of crime in america and how we punish criminals. Was the spread of violence in spite of our laws and courts or because of them and us.
Then we will finally understand what karl menninger was talking about more than 50 years ago in his profound book. Menningers thesis is that most systems of criminal punishment do not achieve any of the purposes by which they are justified, and that our systems of punishment are dehumanizing, extravagantly expensive, and quite ineffective. Menninger s thesis is that most systems of criminal punishment do not achieve any of the purposes by which they are justified, and that our systems of punishment are dehumanizing, extravagantly expensive, and quite ineffective. Karl menninger wrote his landmark book the crime of punishment reflecting his extensive experience as a practitioner in the courts as well as prisons and jails dealing with the interface between psychiatry and the criminal justice system.
Karl augustus menninger july 22, 1893 july 18, 1990, born in topeka, kansas, was an american psychiatrist and a member of the famous menninger family of psychiatrists who founded the menninger foundation and the menninger clinic in topeka, kansas. After assessing the inherent weaknesses of todays penal system the author proposes programs for its restructure and reform. Reading karl menninger of the crime of punishment and whatever happened to sin discussion on world socialist web site 6 comments robert pruett, first imprisoned at age 16, executed in texas despite questions about evidence. As one of the premier rare book sites on the internet, alibris has thousands of rare books, first editions, and signed books available. The crime of punishment is that punishment aggravates crime. Menninger dissected the criminal justice system and concluded, i suspect that all the crimes committed by all the jailed criminals do not equal in the crime of punishment, originally published in 1966, addressed the critical issue of crime in america and how we punish criminals. The crime of punishment, originally published in 1966, addre.
The crime of punishment by karl menninger viking press new york 1968. Man against himself, love against hate, and the vital balance. After receiving his medical degree from harvard medical school 1917, he worked for two years at the. In the crime of punishment, menninger argued that crime was preventable through psychiatric treatment. Menninger, karl article about menninger, karl by the. This book is being republished with the permission of the kansas historical society. Menninger dissected the criminal justice system and concluded, i suspect. Karl set out and elaborated his lifelong view that all the crimes committed by the jailed criminals do not equal in total social damage that of the crimes committed against them.
The crime of punishment by karl menninger a readable copy. Buy a cheap copy of the crime of punishment book by karl a. Karl menninger was one of the most practical and influential psychiatrists in america. The widely read book went through at least 12 printings and a copy was donated to every. Karl augustus menninger was born on july 22 nd, 1893 in topeka, kansas, to charles and florence menninger. Karl a menninger our system of penology is remarkably ineffective, says the. Menninger put it, those who asked us to spare a thought for the victims were being melodramatic and. Menningers ideas for a more effective criminal justice system. Find the crime of punishment 0670002747 by menninger, karl. The crime of punishment 0670002747 by menninger, karl.
Menninger, recognized by many as the father of american psychiatry, died last week at the age of 96. When he was a young man visiting his dentist, he brought up his fathers dramatic pronouncement about setting up a family clinic, and his dentist said that anyone should be honored to work with his esteemed father. His 1966 book the crime of punishment argued that all punishment is cruel and useless and that criminal behavior should instead be treated as mental illness. Shop the latest titles by karl menninger at alibris including hardcovers, paperbacks, 1st editions, and audiobooks from thousands of sellers worldwide. Menninger, karl the crime of punishment 1st edition thus. Karl augustus menninger july 22, 1893 july 18, 1990. Pages can include considerable notesin pen or highlighterbut the notes cannot obscure the text. The crime of punishment by karl menninger and a great selection of related books, art and collectibles available now at. Hello fellow wikipedians, i have just modified 2 external links on. Menningers suggested reforms for our system include 1 trial. His 1966 book the crime of punishment argued that all punishment is cruel. In the crime of punishment, he suggested that crime was preventable through psychiatric treatment and punishment was a brutal and inefficient relic of the past.
323 1372 687 255 307 898 1172 479 1325 641 895 401 1426 651 211 192 120 739 883 1442 719 1195 447 718 309 713 1212 716 407 651 477 451 1081 1010 608 1254 1335 661 348 1038 354 986 606 427 23 1030 1065 1230